Posts Tagged Health
Life’s Too Short to Understand the PCT Funding Formula
Posted by Nigel Williams in Health, Politics on 02/08/2011
Following the announcement of new funding formulae for NHS primary care trusts, accusations have begun about political bias. Manchester, says a report by Public Health Manchester, would lose £42m. Tower Hamlets would lose £19m, whereas Surrey and Hampshire would gain £113m between them.
In any such reallocation, beneficiaries are likely to conclude that the new version is fairer, whereas anyone losing out will prefer the old version. The Yorkshire Evening Post quotes Maureen Idle of Leeds Hospital Alert as saying “If the money has been given in the first place then there’s clearly an acknowledgement that it’s needed.” Read the rest of this entry »
George Monbiot almost says something sensible
Posted by Nick Cowen in Health on 12/03/2008
But not quite. His latest article on Comment is Free is headlined ‘Making GPs more accessible is just a disguised concession to big business’. Although his ideology is almost unparalleled in its economic illiteracy, it looks on the face as if he might have happened upon something important. He starts off well, pointing out that the government’s move to force GPs to open out-of-hours, lacks the significant public backing that is claimed, with evidence cooked up by a cabinet office report and a CBI poll.
Improvements, but still cause for concern
Posted by James Gubb in Health on 06/11/2007
A report released last Friday by Civitas, looking at trends in avoidable mortality, found real improvements had been made in England and Wales; avoidable mortality from cancer fell by 15.0% and from circulatory disease by 34.0% between 1999 and 2005. But while this compares quite favourably with improvements made in many European countries, real cause for concern does remain:
• The decline in avoidable deaths from cancer has been less step since 1999, at odds with trends since 1979; which must surely question the effectiveness of NHS Cancer Plan with all the extra money that has come with it.
• Avoidable mortality rates from circulatory disease remain far above most European countries of comparable development. Assuming the best performing country, France, made no improvements in the coming years, and the NHS continued to improve at the same rate as between 1999-2004, it would still take until about 2019 for us to catch up.
The full report may be viewed here.
A prescription for disaster
Posted by Nick Cowen in Civil Liberty, Health on 24/10/2007
Professor Julian Le Grand has a radical strategy for tackling the supposed problems of ill health in the UK: smoking permits (which might require a doctor’s note), an ‘exercise hour’ for company employees, a ban on additional salt in foods, more free fruit in general and more stern notes sent to the homes of children that have been found to be obese. Le Grand calls this broad sweep of measures ‘libertarian paternalism’, claiming, perversely that none of these actually restrict individual freedom. Wouldn’t ‘libertarian paternalism’ be more normally understood as a friendly word of advice without the backing of force?
Manufacturing Concern
Posted by Nick Cowen in Civil Liberty, Crime, Health on 02/05/2007
Last week, Alcohol Concern, ‘the National Agency on Alcohol Misuse’, managed to generate a significant amount of media coverage with its recommendation to ‘make it illegal to provide alcohol to anyone under the age of 15.’ The reasoning behind this was that since unsupervised consumption of alcohol is spiralling, along with associated anti-social behaviour, among young people, the natural solution is to imprison parents who offer a thimble of wine to their child at the dinner table.
When faced with that as a consequence of their proposal on the BBC’s Today programme, Alcohol Concern’s spokesperson argued that the change in the law was still necessary in order to ‘send a message’. I am not sure what sort of message about this society would be sent out if Jewish Passover services (where every family member is encouraged to drink a traditional sweet red wine throughout the evening) were raided by the police, but I doubt the delinquents in town centres will see the relevance to them. The alternative ‘message’, that such laws won’t be enforced to the letter so best to work out one’s own interpretation of justice would be the likely unintended consequence.
No jobs? Let them have prizes!
Posted by Nick Cowen in Health on 07/03/2007
The NHS remains in crisis. More catastrophes barely make an impression on the British public. They no longer seem to make a difference: the NHS limps on with the efforts of the doctors and nurses that still treat medicine as a vocation. Some targets are hit, others are missed, and amid the crushing burden of admin and the monthly crop of scandals, hospitals and surgeries force through some limited health provision.